February 14, 2023— There are many different vehicles for charitable giving that can help support your objectives and create a philanthropic legacy. Charitable giving is an important discussion to have with your advisors to determine whether your charitable giving is best done individually or through a trust, a private foundation, donor advised fund, or another entity. In this podcast, Director of Wealth Strategies Kerry Reeves discusses the differences between a donor advised fund and a private foundation and how to determine if either strategy would be optimal for your charitable giving.
Choosing Between a Private Foundation and a Donor Advised Fund for Your Charitable Giving
Hi, thank you for tuning into today’s Emerald GEM, which stands for Get Educated in Minutes. I’m Kerry Reeves, Director of Wealth Strategies for Wilmington Trust Emerald Family Office & Advisory® and your host for today’s podcast. In today’s GEM, I’m going to discuss the difference between a donor advised fund and a private foundation and how to determine if either strategy would be optimal for your charitable giving.
Let’s get started.
I’ll start by telling you (1) what a private foundation is and (2) what a donor advised fund is.
A private foundation is a nonprofit corporation or charitable trust that qualifies for tax-exempt status under the internal revenue code. A private foundation is organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, or educational purposes. Making a contribution to a private foundation may qualify you for a charitable deduction. Typically, a private foundation receives its funding from one family or one business. For the right client, a private foundation may be the best way to leave a philanthropic legacy.
An example of how a private foundation might work is that I could establish “Kerry’s Private Foundation.” Each year, I, or perhaps other members of my family, could make charitable contributions to the foundation and use those contributions as income tax deductions. Each year the private foundation would make grants for one or more charitable causes, as the trustees or the board of directors may determine. In addition, upon my death, my estate plan may leave some or all of my assets to the foundation. This would qualify my estate for an estate tax deduction and the private foundation would continue leaving a legacy that may last for generations.
There are, of course, advantages and potential disadvantages to using a private foundation as your charitable vehicle.
Let’s start with some of the advantages:
Now, of course, there are some potential disadvantages (or at least considerations) to establishing a private foundation:
a. An excise tax of currently 1.39% on net investment income4
b. Minimum annual distribution requirements—which is generally 5% of the net fair-market-value of the foundation’s assets on a rolling basis
c. Prohibition on self-dealing
d. Prohibition on excess business holdings (with limited exceptions)
e. Limitation on high-risk investments; and
f. A private foundation must avoid certain taxable expenditures
Every tax-exempt charitable organization is classified as either a private foundation or a public charity. While a tax-exempt organization, a private foundation does not meet any test which, under the internal revenue code, would qualify it as a public charity.
A “public charity” generally receives at least one-third of its funding from the general public and is typically run by a larger board that is representative of the communities it serves. Some of the most well-known nonprofit organizations are public charities, such as the American Red Cross, the United Way, the Salvation Army, and similar organizations. There are certain benefits to being a public charity. The additional restrictions and excise taxes that I mentioned applying to private foundations generally do not apply to public charities. In addition, contributions made to a public charity enjoy a higher adjusted gross income deduction limitation—currently 60%.2
So why am I talking about public charities when this GEM is focused on private foundations and donor advised funds? Well, a donor advised fund, which is commonly referred to as a “DAF,” is a type of public charity. So, when someone says they have a DAF, what that means is they have an account at a DAF. The account is created at an existing grantmaking charitable organization. For instance, many large financial institutions have established donor advised funds for their clients to contribute to as part of their charitable giving strategy.
So, for example, if I wanted to fund a DAF, I could simply go to a financial institution that has one in existence and set up an account. It might even be named “The Kerry Fund.” Each year I could make charitable contributions to the DAF and receive an income tax deduction. And each year, I would “advise” the DAF sponsor on how I would like charitable grants made from the account. Upon my death, I could leave assets to the DAF, which would qualify my estate for an estate tax deduction, and then the next generation (or a named successor) may have the ability to continue to advise and recommend grants from the DAF.
Again, there are, of course, advantages and potential disadvantages to using a donor advised fund as your charitable vehicle.
Let’s, again, start with the advantages:
Now, of course, the potential disadvantages (or at least considerations) to using a DAF:
With that said, your charitable objective will play a large role in determining the charitable vehicle that is most optimal for your planning purposes. As you may have deduced, many of the objectives an individual is looking to achieve by establishing a private foundation can be also achieved by using a donor advised fund and potentially in a more efficient manner. Typically, I like to say that if we are looking at smaller dollars, a DAF is more efficient than establishing a private foundation. For large dollars, a private foundation may be most optimal as it provides for a greater level of control and may be in existence for many generations. Finally, private foundations and donor advised funds are not mutually exclusive. An individual or family may incorporate both into their charitable giving strategy.
While the midterm elections are behind us, and as we approach the next election season, I want to add this important note: Neither a private foundation nor a donor advised fund is an appropriate vehicle for making political contributions. A political contribution coming from a private foundation, or a donor advised fund can, in fact, cause very serious tax consequences. Perhaps a topic for a future GEM.
So, today, I have merely scratched the surface on private foundations and donor advised funds. There are many different vehicles for charitable giving that can support your objectives and create a philanthropic legacy. Charitable giving is an important discussion to have with your advisors in order to determine whether your charitable giving is best done individually or through a trust, a private foundation, donor advised fund, or another entity.
Sources:
1 IRC Section 170
2 IRC Section 170; Under 2017 tax reform, the deduction limit for cash gifts to public charities was increased from 50% to 60%. The 60% limit is scheduled to revert back in 2026.
3 Regulatory excise tax provisions of Chapter 42 of the Internal Revenue Code
4 IRC Section 4940(a)
Definition of Terms
Adjusted gross income (“AGI”): Defined as gross income minus adjustments to income. Gross income includes your wages, dividends, capital gains, business income, retirement distributions as well as other income. Adjustments to income include such items as Educator expenses, Student loan interest, Alimony payments or contributions to a retirement account.
Basis deduction: Deduction limited to a property’s basis, the amount of capital investment in property for tax purposes.
Donor advised fund: A public charity that affords donors the benefit of a charitable deduction at the public charity contribution base limitation. See IRC Section 170.
Excess benefit transaction: A transaction in which an economic benefit is provided by an applicable tax-exempt organization, directly or indirectly, to or for the use of a disqualified person, and the value of the economic benefit provided by the organization exceeds the value of the consideration received by the organization.
Fair market value (“FMV”): The price that property would sell for on the open market. It is the price that would be agreed on between a willing buyer and a willing seller, with neither being required to act, and both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.
Incidental donor benefits: A benefit is considered more than incidental if, because of a charitable contribution, the donor receives a benefit that would reduce or eliminate the charitable contribution deduction if the benefit were received as part of the transaction.
Wilmington Trust Emerald Family Office & Advisory® is a registered trademark and refers to wealth planning, family office and advisory services provided by Wilmington Trust, N.A., a member of the M&T family. Wilmington Family Office is a service mark for an offering of family office and advisory services provided by Wilmington Trust, N.A.
The information provided herein is for informational purposes only and is not intended as a recommendation or determination that any tax, estate planning, or investment strategy is suitable for a specific investor. Note that tax, estate planning, investing, and financial strategies require consideration for suitability of the individual, business, or investor, and there is no assurance that any strategy will be successful.
Wilmington Trust is not authorized to and does not provide legal or accounting advice. Wilmington Trust does not provide tax advice, except where we have agreed to provide tax preparation services to you. Our advice and recommendations provided to you are illustrative only and subject to the opinions and advice of your own attorney, tax advisor, or other professional advisor.
The information in this podcast has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. The opinions, estimates, and projections constitute the judgment of Wilmington Trust and are subject to change without notice.
Third-party trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.
What can we help you with today